Back to Blog
Foundations

When your cholesterol comes back high

By Lauza Loistl··5 min read

You open the result on your phone, or you get the letter, and there it is. One line, often in bold or in red, telling you your cholesterol is high. Maybe a note to cut down on fatty food. Maybe a mention of a statin. Maybe nothing more than the number itself, left to sit there and worry you. And so you start eating differently the next morning, or you book the appointment, or you quietly decide you are someone with a cholesterol problem now.

Before any of that, it helps to know how to read what you are actually looking at.

One number on one day is a snapshot, not the story. To read cholesterol properly you look at the whole panel together, not LDL alone, and more than anything you look at the direction it is moving across a few tests, alongside what your inflammation and liver markers are doing. A single high LDL reading is a reason to look closer, not a verdict to act on in a hurry.

Let me show you what I mean with a real example. A client of mine, a man in his early fifties, gave me permission to share his numbers. His LDL across three tests read 168, then 191.6, then 162.4. Here is the fuller picture.

Marker First test Middle test Latest test
LDL 168 191.6 162.4
Total cholesterol 234 266 235
HDL 49 52 55
Triglycerides 86 112 88

(These figures are in one of the common units labs use. In the UK many reports use a different scale, so the numbers look smaller. What matters is not the unit but the trend, read consistently on your own report.)

Look at the middle column. If this man had walked in for a one-off test on that day, he would have been handed his highest reading of the three and told, quite reasonably, that things were getting worse. But that single number would have been misleading. Cholesterol genuinely moves from test to test, by something like a tenth either way for LDL even in a steady person,1 which is why one result can land high or low by chance. The story was never in any single column. It was in the line they draw together.

So here is how to read a panel, in plain terms. LDL is the cholesterol most strongly tied to the slow furring of the arteries, and over a lifetime it does causally drive that process, which is why it gets the attention it does.2 HDL is the kind that tends to be protective, so higher is usually the better direction there. Triglycerides are a separate fat in the blood that often tracks with sugar, refined carbohydrate and alcohol more than with dietary fat. And then there are the markers that sit alongside, like inflammation and liver stress, that tell you whether the body is calm or under strain. No single one of these is the whole answer. They are a conversation, and they only make sense read together.

This is what a fast, standard response tends to miss. A single LDL number triggers a single reflex, cut the fat or start the tablet, without anyone asking the more useful questions. Why did it move. What is the rest of the panel saying. Is there inflammation or liver strain underneath it. And, the question almost no one asks, how does this particular body handle fat in the first place. Two people can walk in with an identical LDL and be in genuinely different situations, needing genuinely different things.

That last point is the one I find most people have never been told, and it is where this gets interesting. Some of how your body handles fat, and oxidation, and blood pressure, is written into your genes, and it can mean the advice that works beautifully for your neighbour does very little for you. That is what I want to look at next, in the second part of this short series.

For now, the takeaway is gentler than the red flag on your screen suggests. A high reading is information, not a sentence. When someone comes to me with a result like this, we do not start with a protocol pulled off a shelf. We start by reading the whole picture, across time, and working out what is actually going on for this person, in this body, right now.

If your cholesterol has come back high and you feel rushed toward a single answer, it is worth slowing down enough to read the result properly first, and to take a clearer look before you decide anything.

References

  1. A person’s LDL cholesterol naturally varies between tests, with a within-person biological variation of roughly 9 to 10 percent, so a single reading can land notably high or low by chance; one analysis found that 28 percent of middle-aged men with a single result above a cut-off actually had a long-term average below it. Cooper GR et al., The variability of serum cholesterol measurements: implications for screening and monitoring — Clinical Chemistry, 1990. 

  2. A consensus review of genetic, epidemiological and trial evidence concluded that LDL has a causal and cumulative effect on atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, not merely an associated one. Ference BA et al., Low-density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. 1. Evidence from genetic, epidemiologic, and clinical studies — European Heart Journal (EAS Consensus Panel), 2017. 

This article is for education, not medical advice, and it isn't a substitute for personalised care. If any of it feels relevant to you, speak with a qualified practitioner about testing and what's right for your situation.

Lauza Loistl
Written by
Lauza Loistl
DipNT, CNM · Registered member of the ANP

Naturopathic nutritional therapist working online on women's health: hormones, fertility, and gut, and the kind of tiredness that builds up over years.

More about Lauza
If this sounds like you

Let's find what actually works for you.

Reading about it only gets you so far. A free 15-minute discovery call is where we look at your symptoms, your habits, and your actual days, and start working out what your body needs right now — a sense of whether I'm the right person to help.

Not ready to book?

Each week I write to help you understand your body and leave with one small change you can actually make, because feeling well changes how the rest of life feels. The Sunday letter also brings my new discoveries, workshops, events, and occasional news. Five minutes on a Sunday. Unsubscribe any time.